Blog
Ask nutrition directors why their programs haven’t changed and you’ll get a dozen different answers. On the newest episode of Cafeteria Confessions, Nancy Easton, executive director and founder of Wellness in the Schools (WITS), which now reaches more than a million students across 2,000-plus schools, names five specific, structural barriers standing between where most cafeterias are today and where they could be tomorrow: funding, outdated infrastructure, procurement restrictions, staffing, and policy. After two decades building programs from the ground up, she’s watched every one of these barriers up close. Here’s what each one actually looks like inside a real cafeteria, and where a program can realistically start.
Barrier One: Funding That Doesn’t Match the Job
Federal reimbursement was never designed to cover the full cost of a modern, scratch-forward meal program. It has to stretch across food, labor, equipment, and every other operating expense. That gap doesn’t show up as a single line item; it shows up as reheated instead of roasted, canned instead of fresh, and menu decisions made around what’s affordable rather than what’s ideal. Closing it takes layering federal dollars with grants, local funding, and partnerships, rather than waiting for reimbursement rates to catch up on their own.
Barrier Two: Infrastructure Built for a Different Era
Many school kitchens were built decades ago around reheating pre-prepared food, not cooking from scratch. Without cold storage, combi ovens, or enough prep space, even a motivated team hits a physical ceiling on what it can produce. Infrastructure investment is slow and capital-intensive, but it’s also the barrier with the clearest fix: equipment grants, phased capital planning, and prioritizing the handful of upgrades that unlock the most menu flexibility.
Barrier Three: Procurement Rules That Work Against Local, Fresh Food
Federal procurement requirements exist for good reasons, but they were built around large-scale, shelf-stable purchasing, and they can make it genuinely hard to buy from a nearby farm or small producer. Programs that want to source locally often have to build relationships and paperwork processes that go well beyond a standard vendor contract, which is exactly why so few do it without dedicated support.
Barrier Four: Staffing Gaps That Compound Every Other Problem
None of the other four barriers matter much if there aren’t enough trained hands to execute on them. Understaffed kitchens default to whatever requires the least labor, regardless of what the equipment or the budget could otherwise support. Training programs, career pathways, and realistic staffing ratios aren’t a nice-to-have here. They’re the precondition for every other reform actually landing on a tray.
Barrier Five: Policy That Hasn’t Caught Up
Meal pattern requirements, procurement law, and reimbursement structures all move slower than the research on what actually works in a school cafeteria. That lag isn’t an excuse to wait for policy to change before improving a program, but it does mean programs that want to move faster than the rules sometimes have to build the case, program by program, for what the next round of policy should require.
Where to Start
- None of this is meant to be tackled all at once. A few practical starting points:
- Map your program against these five barriers honestly. Most programs are held back by two or three, not all five equally, and that’s where the leverage is.
- Start with the barrier that’s cheapest to move. Staffing training and procurement relationship-building often cost less than a full equipment overhaul and can unlock progress while bigger capital requests work through the budget cycle.
- Look for programs already solving the barrier you’re stuck on. Nancy Easton’s ScratchWorks initiative, covered in this week’s second post, is a working example worth studying.
- Build the case with data, not impressions. A clear before-and-after on cost per meal, participation, or waste makes the next investment easier to justify internally.
Not every barrier can be removed, and not every challenge is within a program’s control. But understanding what is holding your program back can help you focus on where you do have influence. Real progress comes from identifying those opportunities, taking practical steps, and continuing to build on what works.
Listen to “What It Really Takes To Fix School Food” on Cafeteria Confessions here.